Security ·
New wallet-key draft tackles recovery differences for hash-based signatures
A 13 November Ethereum Magicians draft proposes a common method for deriving hash-based post-quantum keys from a BIP-39 recovery phrase. ERC-8499 seeks to make compatible wallets derive the same keys. It is a proposal seeking feedback, not an adopted wallet requirement.
The author identifies a practical problem: different derivation methods can turn the same phrase into different keys, so entering a backup into another wallet may not recover the expected account. The proposed method uses the BIP-39 seed with hash-based derivation and avoids BIP-32's elliptic-curve hierarchy.
The draft separates reusable stateless keys from stateful one-time signing material, whose recovery needs different handling to avoid dangerous reuse. It includes test vectors and implementation work, but that does not establish industry adoption. There is no instruction here to enter an existing phrase into a new tool or migrate a live wallet.
One spare key should fit the same door twice. An unfashionably useful ambition for a standard.
The receipts
Worth passing round?
Send the story to a friend, or take Bumpy’s verdict card with you.

Have a question about this?
Take this story into our Telegram community. Bring a source, a question or a well-placed eyebrow.
Opens the community invite. Paste the story link into the conversation; nothing is sent automatically.This is the 14 November 2026 edition. Facts may have developed since publication. Read the latest briefing →
